sladerunner69
Member
the reason piana looked healthy (which he didnt if you paid a closer look) to some people, is because he would be super healthy if he was carrying an insane amount of muscle like that around under normal circumstances (no steroids) . and i think thats the point that the person in this thread wanted to make ,even though it was misunderstood by many.
so muscles are a sign of strength and expecially of health thats why women are biologically drawn to them.
its of course not the same if you force your body to carry unphysiological amounts of muscle by taking anabolic steroids in crazy dosages...
and to all the others that say they dont care how he looks because his diet makes them feel good. just think about that there are thousands of people that swear that the keto or paleo diet made them feel good. i do believe that it made them feel good.although that shouldnt be the only relevenat thing to look for when accsesing a diet . it is an improtant one though!
Actually I'm going to disagree with all of your main points... being insanely muscular (Even if that guy's muscularity was somehow at all possible without steroids) is NOT a sign of good health. The primary factor in muscle mass is testosterone levels, the research makes this clear. Some guys can gain 10 lbs of muscle in a month just from taking steroids and not changing anything else. However, having high testosterone levels is not necessarily healthy. Ideally, you would want a good portion of the testosterone being converted to DHT, a hormone that helps lower bodyfat and has plenty of nice qualities but does not increase muscle size at all. Also, you would want very little of this testosterone to convert over to estrogen, which is very unlikely. It only takes a little testosterone to create a lot of estrogen during a stress. Most steroid users are under heavy stress, and so take "aromatase-inhibitors" to keep their estrogen levels in check, but when measuring the levels are still significant, much higher than where I would want them to be healthy and prevent cancer, for example. So hormonally speaking, I would not want my testosterone levels as high as D*ck Piano's which I would assume to be at least 2000 dg/ml. The standard healthy range is from 400-800, and some bodybuilders taking steroids have tested as high as 5000 which in my opinion is just bananas. Even if that were possible naturally, that could not be healthy because you would have to have low DHT and high estrogen. Also haidut wrote about an Islander Tribe, I think the Maori, were very muscular, had no body hair and small genitals with low libido. They were tested for high testosterone, high estrogen, and low DHT.
Other problems with using muscle mass as a health metric are the diet and training. Both of these have to be bad and stressful if to maximize muscle growth. The diet which has proven to increase muscle mass the most are diets very high in muscle meats because these proteins stimulate muscle growth the most, as Peat says. But muscle meats also cause inflammation and increased serotonin and related problems. Most bodybuilding diets also call for very little saturated fats and eating most unsaturated fat, in my experience, and this would further increase stress, along with cutting carbohydrates when trying to get ripped and lean. Eating a diet of nothing but muscle meat, canola oil, and a couple bowls of oatmeal is certainly not healthy from Peat's view.
The training which maximizes muscle growth can also be very stressful. Most bodybuilders who are serious about building mass and bulking up with train for about an hour or two. This is far too long. Scientific publications have generally reached a consensus that the optimal weight training program for health purposes is very short and less frequent, most say 3 times a week for 45 minutes, although I have read a compelling argument for one 15 minute workout every 7-10 days. This is because the amount of weight lifting and level of intensity that bodybuilders like to do, that amount compromises joint and nervous system health, and keeps stress hormones elevated. It only takes 30 minutes of weightlifting or less for the liver to expend all of its glycogen, and then you are running on pure stress- estrogen, cortisol, and adrenaline. That is not healthy...