OP
somuch4food
Member
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2018
- Messages
- 1,281
Grant's theory isn't incomplete, it's incorrect. You've got to realize there's an astronomical difference between toxicity and poison. Toxicity is too much of a good thing can become bad. This isn't the argument that Grant and his supporters are arguing. They consider vitamin A a poison, and any amount, regardless of the individual and their unique current status, is wrong for consuming it. The science is heavily skewed against this claim, not to mention Grant's lack of intelligence in the scientific field makes this a open and shut case.
Come on guys. If you have something against the theory, go over to the freaking thread: Grant Genereux's Theory Of Vitamin A Toxicity
Sorry that I'm rude, but I've mentioned many times that I do not want a debate HERE. I don't care whether the theory is valid or not. It's working for many, including the moderators of this forum. It worked for me the first time around.
I am acknowledging that Grant's case could be too much of a good thing, but why did it have so much impact over his health even though he only supplemented for a few years with CLO pills. Carotenoids are supposedly safe... He shouldn't be toxic and shouldn't be breaking out because he eats a tomato. Why is that? He reversed a fatal chronic kidney disease for God's sake.
Possibly, but after having some conversations with a few people in the poison A thread I'm kind of turned off to the idea of even approaching his views with an open mind. I've heard all I needed to hear. At this juncture, it has less to do with Grant's views and more to do with how his supporter base is perceiving his views. I mean, I hate drama and don't want to call anyone out personally, but one guy I was talking to on that thread was so misguided that he's approaching tinfoil fat territory. I also did make stop by Grant's website, only to find he's a engineer. Not a medical doctor, not a dietitian, not a physiologist, not a biochemist, or anything of that nature. Engineers are pretty damn smart in their own fields, but it's kind of like asking Albert Einstein's "expertise" in politics, lol.
Why did you come to this thread? Did you not read that I want a practical, constructive conversation, not a DEBATE. If you want to debunk his theory, it's the other thread. If you want to deconstruct this low A diet and find why it works for people than post your experience, studies and theories HERE.