Amazoniac
Member
Now that I've tried both:
Great Lakes has a very mild taste, even powder, lighter color, and you can definitely taste a bit of salt (as mentioned on the label).
Peter's is just the opposite; strong taste (overpowers everything), uneven powder (very fine particles mixed with rough ones), a bit darker, and no salty taste. However, those are all signs of a product that is less processed and the quality seems slightly better on this one. Tastes brothy actually, which is how it's supposed to taste.
To be honest I'd probably decide to have both of them available in case I wanted to use with something or take it separately on a spoon. For me, the shipping price is considerably higher for HealthNatura's which is why I will probably opt for the other; but that would not be a problem for most people since the price should be much lower.
Regarding packages, the can from Great Lakes is better for sure. The bag always creates this powdery cloud whenever you use it, and it's really difficult to prevent the air from doing that to fine powders using bags. But those are minor things that can be easily fixed by a better bag system or switching to a similar can.
I'm sure many people here already tried both and can share their opinion. Also, if anyone tried the one from VitalProteins, please comment.
ps.: Peter's product was sent as a gift from one of those giveaways; so, thank you for that. I just wouldn't be reviewing it if it wasn't a good product.
Great Lakes has a very mild taste, even powder, lighter color, and you can definitely taste a bit of salt (as mentioned on the label).
Peter's is just the opposite; strong taste (overpowers everything), uneven powder (very fine particles mixed with rough ones), a bit darker, and no salty taste. However, those are all signs of a product that is less processed and the quality seems slightly better on this one. Tastes brothy actually, which is how it's supposed to taste.
To be honest I'd probably decide to have both of them available in case I wanted to use with something or take it separately on a spoon. For me, the shipping price is considerably higher for HealthNatura's which is why I will probably opt for the other; but that would not be a problem for most people since the price should be much lower.
Regarding packages, the can from Great Lakes is better for sure. The bag always creates this powdery cloud whenever you use it, and it's really difficult to prevent the air from doing that to fine powders using bags. But those are minor things that can be easily fixed by a better bag system or switching to a similar can.
I'm sure many people here already tried both and can share their opinion. Also, if anyone tried the one from VitalProteins, please comment.
ps.: Peter's product was sent as a gift from one of those giveaways; so, thank you for that. I just wouldn't be reviewing it if it wasn't a good product.